S&P Equity Research Finds Majority of Buybacks Have Disappointing Results

Monitor this Company

Company share repurchase programs rarely a driver of positive performance

    NEW YORK, Nov. 6 // -- While 2007's record-setting stock repurchasing activity may make it the "Year of the Buyback," a recent Standard & Poor's Equity Research study shows this widely practiced strategy to boost company share prices may not lead to the anticipated positive benefits. In fact, Standard & Poor's Equity Research's look at corporate share repurchases among S&P 500 companies over the last 18 months showed that only one out of every four S&P 500 companies (103 companies) that repurchased shares outperformed the Index, while the remainder would have been better off putting their excess cash into an S&P 500 Index exchange-traded fund. This was among the findings from the Standard & Poor's report titled, "How Rewarding Is Corporate Share Repurchase Activity?" which was published today.

    "The tendency is to assume that corporate share repurchases lead to a sustained uptick in stock performance, and the more activity the better," note the study's authors, Stewart Glickman, Associate Director, and Todd Rosenbluth, Senior Associate Director, Standard & Poor's Equity Research. "While these initiatives may create a positive aura around a company's shares, our study showed an inverse link between repurchase activity and the returns achieved - the companies that used buybacks most aggressively actually generated the weakest returns over the course of the study period. Based on these findings, we recommend shareholders take a close look at a company's buyback history and their results before bidding up share prices."

    The study reviewed the buyback activity of the companies comprising the S&P 500 for 18 months ending in June 2007, and compared it to stock prices as of the quarter ended September 2007. During this timeframe, 423 companies reported share repurchases. For 77 companies, no repurchase activity was found, and these companies were classified as "zero repurchasers." These companies may have engaged in share repurchases that were insignificant and not disclosed within the details of the company's SEC filings.

    "S&P Equity Research undertook this analysis to assess the conventional wisdom on buyback activity and question the decision-making process when using large amounts of shareholder funds for this purpose," said Stephen Biggar, Global Director of Equity Research for S&P. "We believe that share buybacks may sometimes be a subtle admittance by managements that re-investing in their core operations does not represent a good opportunity. Therefore, we are not surprised that some of the most aggressive repurchasers on our list had the worst track records. S&P Equity Research was uniquely positioned to undertake this study given its breadth of coverage, globally consistent fundamental research methodology and demonstrated thought leadership in equity market analysis."

    Members of the media can request a copy of the Executive Summary of this report from the communications contact listed at the end of this release.

    The analysts quoted above are Standard & Poor's equity analysts. They have no affiliation with any company they cover, nor any ownership interest in any companies they cover.

    About Standard & Poor's Equity Research Services

    As the world's largest producer of independent equity research, Standard & Poor's licenses its research to over 1,000 institutions for their investors and advisors, including 19 of the top 20 securities firms, 13 of the top 20 banks, and 11 of the top 20 life insurance companies. Standard & Poor's team of 120 experienced U.S., European and Asian equity analysts use a fundamental, bottom-up approach to assess a global universe of approximately 2,000 equities across more than 120 industries worldwide. Follow Standard & Poor's equity analysts' U.S. market commentary each day at http://www.equityresearch.standardandpoors.com/.

    The equity research reports and recommendations provided by Standard & Poor's Equity Research Services are performed separately from any other analytic activity of Standard & Poor's. Standard & Poor's Equity Research Services has no access to non-public information received by other units of Standard & Poor's. Standard & Poor's does not trade for its own account. The analytical and ethical conduct of Standard & Poor's equity analysts is governed by the firm's Research Objectivity Policy, a copy of which may also be found at http://www.standardandpoors.com or by clicking here.

    About Standard & Poor's

    Standard & Poor's, a division of The McGraw-Hill Companies (NYSE: MHP), is the world's foremost provider of financial market intelligence, including independent credit ratings, indices, risk evaluation, investment research and data. With approximately 8,500 employees, including wholly owned affiliates, located in 21 countries, Standard & Poor's is an essential part of the world's financial infrastructure and has played a leading role for more than 140 years in providing investors with the independent benchmarks they need to feel more confident about their investment and financial decisions. For more information, visit http://www.standardandpoors.com.

    For more information contact:

     Jeff Sexton


     Standard & Poor's

     Equity Research

     212 438 3448

Monitor this Company :
You will receive an email alert whenever there is a news item concerning this company.
Name Your Company
Email Address Position/Role

2001 - 2016 Lexdon Business Library
About TrustBase
Privacy Policy